Taylor vs. Catterall 2: End of the Road for Josh Taylor?
By Chris Carlson
PhilBoxing.com
Sat, 25 May 2024
How much gasoline does Josh Taylor have left in his tank as we approach Saturday’s long due rematch? Add to the fact Josh is coming off his only pro loss of his career to Teofimo Lopez. Adding another layer the bout being fought at junior welterweight, equates to the odds stacked against the Scotland native. It wasn’t the prettiest of prizefights between Jack Catterall and Josh Taylor. At times it was slow and sloppy but it was very close. Who will come out on top in this main event rematch streaming live on DAZN?
Neither boxer has been active since their split-decision result back in early 2022. The edge could be given to Jack Catterall for fighting twice in 2023. One could also point out Jack’s competition was nowhere near the likes of Teofimo Lopez especially on a good day which it was for Teo that June night. The biggest sticking point for this boxing podcaster is the weight. For so long we’ve heard how Josh Taylor cannot make the 140-pound limit so don’t be shocked if you hear about a late installed catchweight of sorts come Friday.
On the surface it would appear that Josh Taylor is the more talented boxer yet he sure didn’t show it in their first meeting. Catterall’s left hand was a key weapon for him eventually scoring a knockdown in the 8th round. Jack used a snappy jab along with left hands landing to the head and body to contain Taylor for the most part. He also used a poor man’s shoulder roll defense in spots to fend off Taylor’s offense, many times while on or near the ropes. The two kept tying up on the inside but it was Jack timing Taylor which disrupted Josh’s rhythm for a large part of the contest.
Taylor also kept leaning over up close on the inside which he ended up paying the price for it when Jack landed two left hands. One grazed Taylor but the second one landed near the temple dropping Josh to the canvas. Taylor didn’t even land 100 punches in the fight throwing a little over 300 to Jack’s 120 landed punches and more active throwing 525. Catterall more than doubled Josh on jabs landed and thrown, body work being the only advantage for Taylor. Both men had points deducted, Taylor for hitting after the bell and Catterall for holding.
Josh Taylor has expressed fear of not getting a fair shake from the officials on fight night. Whether that amounts to anything in reality has yet to be seen. This rematch could come down to Jack having Josh’s number. Like many boxers after losing for the first time, Josh changed trainers. Taylor also believes he has changed his regimen enough to make the junior welterweight class once again. Taylor is the underdog ranging from +112 to +130. This boxing junkie is hesitant to throw much down on the fight because of the over the hill vibe coming from Taylor’s last two outings. Josh only fighting for the second time in over two years is very concerning.
To be fair it’s not like we should have a ton of confidence in Jack. This is a tough one to call and regardless of the style matchup has a high level of intrigue written all over it. Look for it to be a somewhat similar fight to the first one with Josh Taylor being effective enough making slight adjustments to pull it off. +126 on mybookie is too high to pass up in my humble opinion. If you feel the same and think it goes the distance, Josh Taylor by decision is +246. Let’s hope for another two-way fight with more action this time around.
My Official Prediction is Josh Taylor by Majority-Decision.
PODCAST LINK: https://t.co/4n9eoYwEBM
Written by Chris Carlson Host/Producer of The Rope A Dope Radio Podcast Available at www.blogtalkradio.com/ropeadoperadio Follow on Twitter @RopeADopeRadio
Click here to view a list of other articles written by Chris Carlson.
Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:
Xander Zayas: "It's Time to Make History!"
Thu, 15 Jan 2026Weights from Trenton, NJ
Thu, 15 Jan 2026Pro Boxer and Recent Grad Returns for Fight Night on the Farm — Celebrating Stanford’s Boxing Community
Thu, 15 Jan 2026Jamaine Ortiz Aims to Derail Keyshawn Davis’ Undefeated Streak at Madison Square Garden
Wed, 14 Jan 2026“No bad blood from me”- Good friends become better rivals – Clarke is ready for Cruiserweight title Clash March 13 in Perth – Thunderdome 53
Wed, 14 Jan 2026Itauma suffers injury; Magnificent 7 rescheduled to March 28
By Gabriel F. Cordero, Wed, 14 Jan 2026Top Super Lightweights Bryan Flores & Starling Castillo Battle in 10-Round Main Event of ProBoxTV’s ‘The Contender Series’
Wed, 14 Jan 2026Harden surpasses Shaquille O'Neal's to become the ninth all-time leading scorer in NBA history
By Gabriel F. Cordero, Wed, 14 Jan 2026“It’s time, LFG” - Holly McMath Trilogy for WBC Title Clash March 13 in Perth – Thunderdome 53
Tue, 13 Jan 2026IBA President Kremlev encourages sporting organisations to protect women’s sport following Trump’s statement on Imane Khelif
Tue, 13 Jan 2026REYES, STRICKLAND, BUSTAMANTE & SOUQUET SET FOR HISTORIC SHOWDOWN AT WNT LEGENDS – EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW
Tue, 13 Jan 2026Pumicpic fights Korean in Japan
By Lito delos Reyes, Tue, 13 Jan 2026No. 1 rated WBA Super Flyweight contender John “Scrappy” Ramirez remains patient and Looks forward to a 2026 World title shot
Tue, 13 Jan 2026Ironman 70.3 Davao on March 22
By Lito delos Reyes, Tue, 13 Jan 2026THE PAST WEEK IN ACTION 12 JANUARY 2026: Dalton Smith Halts Subriel Matias in 5; Kabayel Stops Knyba in 3
By Eric Armit, Mon, 12 Jan 2026