SUAREZ SETTLES FOR SILVER; JUDGES' DECISIONS UNDER FIRE
By Ronnie Nathanielsz
PhilBoxing.com
Fri, 03 Oct 2014
The last man standing in the Philippines boxing team?s quest for gold, lightweight Charly Suarez had to settle for a silver medal when he failed to duplicate his winning form in the Kazakhstan?s President Cup where he handily defeated Mongolia?s Otgondalai Dorjnyambuu, losing in his rematch with the tough Mongolian who deserved the victory.
In an Asian Games boxing tournament rife with controversy, protests and accusations of fixed fights the Kazakhstan judge inexplicably scored the bout by a 30-27 shutout for Suarez who lost the first two rounds and was only able to mount a comeback in the final round.
The judges from Argentina and Italy both saw it, 29-28, for Dorjnyambuu as we did in the coverage over TV 5.
It was the third silver medal of the games for the Philippine contingent after Wushu bets Daniel Parantac and Jean Claude Saclag won silver medals.
Three of the Filipino boxers who clearly won their bouts but lost the decisions on the scorecards of the judges, had to be content with bronze medals with Olympian Mark Anthony Barriga who lost a heartbreaker to hometown boxer Shin Jonghun who went on to give the Koreans their first gold medal with a shutout 30-27 unanimous decision over Zhakypov Birzhan of Kazakhstan.
Bantamweight Mario Fernandez who out-boxed China?s Zhang Jiawei but lost in another seriously questionable decision also wound up with a silver medal although the Chinese fighter suffered the same fate when he hammered South Korea?s Sangmyeong Han only to react in disbelief after the Korean was awarded the decision.
Middleweight Wilfredo Lopez who outclassed Jordan?s Alhindawi Odai Riyad Odel in the semi finals but again was robbed of a well-deserved victory with the Jordanian southpaw himself looking distraught after being rocked a few times by the power-punching Lopez.
The Jordanian did a dance after stepping out of the ring, obviously delighted at his good fortune but, as expected, he was no match for Kazakhstan?s Alimkhanuly Zhanibek in the battle for gold.
The judging in boxing and the actuations of the South Korean officials came under bitter attack from several delegations with the Indian and Mongolian delegations filing formal protests over blatantly bum decisions which, as expected, were rejected by the Koreans with the Thais and even the Chinese voicing their outrage.
The Philippines Ricky Vargas, the respected president of the Amateur Boxing Alliance of the Philippines who was the first to accept the fact that Suarez lost in his fight for gold, blasted the ?hometown decisions?, citing in particular the decision that robbed Barriga of a chance for a gold medal when the 21 year old who was certain he had won after a masterful showing jumped for joy only to be deflated by the decision.
Vargas couldn?t believe that the judges gave the decision to the South Korean whose face was heavily marked from the fury of Barriga?s punches.
The talented little fighter who was considered the Philippines best bet for a boxing gold medal said the result was not right even as he expressed the hope that the next time around the judges would be fair.
He said he caught the Korean with ?strong and clear punches? telling the French news agency AFP ?My goal was gold but bronze is what God gave me.?
Rather than refuse the medal like India?s female boxer Sarita who wept after the decision awarding her fight to a Korean girl was announced, Barriga ?I wull always wear my medal with pride for the Philippines.?
Vargas agreed with the Thais and others who openly claimed it was ?very hard to beat a Korean in Korea. Hometown decisions are very prevalent here in Incheon? even as the India?s Cuban coach alleged that money had changed hands and that some scorecards were prepared even before the fighters entered the ring.
Photo: Suarez (L)in action in Incheon Asian Games.
Click here to view a list of other articles written by Ronnie Nathanielsz.
Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:
Two (or Three) Lefts Make a Right: Francisco Guilledo to Luisito Espinosa
By Emmanuel Rivera, RRT, Thu, 11 Sep 2025Yoseline Perez Advances to 2025 World Boxing Championships Semifinals
Thu, 11 Sep 2025UNIFIED WORLD CHAMPION OSCAR COLLAZO HOSTS MEDIA WORKOUT
Thu, 11 Sep 2025Jerwin Ancajas Set for IBF Mandatory Eliminator Against Former World Champ Ryosuke Nishida; Winner Fights Naoya Inoue
By Carlos Costa, Thu, 11 Sep 2025“Night of Champions” Returns to Caribe Royale Resort in Orlando on September 19
Thu, 11 Sep 2025Local Favorite Bryce Mills Tops First Boxing Card At del Lago Resort & Casino
Thu, 11 Sep 2025Round 12 with Mauricio Sulaiman: It´s Fightweek Fight: Canelo vs. Crawford
By Mauricio Sulaimán, Wed, 10 Sep 2025Casimero comeback next month in Kyrgyzstan?
By Nick Giongco, Wed, 10 Sep 2025Team USA Concludes Day Six of 2025 World Boxing Championships
Wed, 10 Sep 2025Andrade, Garras rule Milo marathon in Tagum
Wed, 10 Sep 2025CROCKER-DONOVAN II: INSIDE LOOK AT FIRST FACE-OFF IN BELFAST
Wed, 10 Sep 2025Former Panamanian WBA champ Jorge Lujan hospitalized
By Gabriel F. Cordero, Wed, 10 Sep 2025Southern Sports Heroes Night on Sept. 28
By Lito delos Reyes, Wed, 10 Sep 2025ABAP feels WB’s growing pains
By Joaquin Henson, Wed, 10 Sep 2025Laurente is new Philippine super featherweight champ
By Lito delos Reyes, Wed, 10 Sep 2025