Araneta Loses on Points in Odd Judging Setup; Still no Japanese World Welterweight Champion
By Teodoro Medina Reynoso
PhilBoxing.com
Fri, 20 Jun 2025
Christian Araneta went down in defeat to long time Japan based Thai fighter Thanomsak Simsri failing in his bid for the vacant IBF world light flyweight championship in Ota City, Japan Thursday.
It was a huge letdown for Araneta who waited two years for the title opportunity despite having been the mandatory challenger for almost that long.
Despite scoring the fight's only knockdown in the third round, Araneta lost by split decision to Simsri, with two Japanese judges giving their cards to the Thai while the third judge, a Pole, casting the dissenting vote in favor of the Filipino.
It was a strange judging set up given the two Japanese judges. It opens questions and suspicions as Simsri, despite being a Thai, can already be considered as a Japan-adopted fighter as Roman Gonzalez and Jorge Linares were before him.
It was also in drastic departure of the practice in world title bouts in Japan where they employed an all neutral panel of judges as seen previously.
Had the organisers adopted the setup of one judge each from the Philippines and Thailand with the Pole as the neutral judge, the split decision verdict could have gone to Araneta.
Even Joe Koizumi, the veteran Japanese correspondent for fightnews.com who first reported on the result, was unconvinced of Simsri's victory, noting that the Thai had barely
acquired the title vacated by Masamishi Yabuki who is now WBA flyweight titlist.
The strange judging set-up came after Japanese fighters failed to win titles in previous world title bouts held in Japan, including those of the Shigeoka brothers, Kazuto Ioka and Tomoki Kameda.
It's intriguing as in the main event with American Brian Norman, Jr. defending his WBO welterweight title against top rated Japanese challenger Jin Sasaki featured an all neutral panel of judges.
The judges did not matter as Norman delivered a concussive fifth round knockout win over Sasaki, rendering Japan still without a world welterweight titlist since adopting pro boxing in the 1950s (The Philippines has one in Manny Pacquiao who could win another reign at advanced age in July).
Could it be that the organizers adopted the strange judging set-up in the Araneta-Simsri fight to give the home fighter (Simsri) the advantage and end the streak of loses to visiting fighters since months ago?
Certainly that losing trend has not been in keeping with Japan being on "a golden age in boxing" as Naoya Inoue loves to say.
The author Teodoro Medina Reynoso is a veteran boxing radio talk show host living in the Philippines. He can be reached at teddyreynoso@yahoo.com and by phone 09215309477.
Click here to view a list of other articles written by Teodoro Medina Reynoso.
Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:
Arnold Barboza Jr. Shines in Welterweight Debut, Defeats Kenneth Sims Jr. to Claim Wbo Global Welterweight Title
Sun, 15 Mar 2026WBC top contender Canoy returns to Davao with Unanimous Decision Victory
Sun, 15 Mar 2026John Randall Peralta: The Future of the Philippine Chess
By Marlon Bernardino, Sun, 15 Mar 2026Alvin “Felemon” Dologuin Claims Win in Brico Santig’s Show in Thailand (PHOTOS)
Sun, 15 Mar 2026Donaire's Yokohama Showdown: Can our Filipino Flash Outshine the Rising Sun? (WEIGH-IN PHOTOS)
By Carlos Costa, Sun, 15 Mar 2026USA Boxing Youth High Performance Team Wins Five of Eight Bouts on Day Six
Sun, 15 Mar 2026Shai Gilgeous-Alexander surpasses Chamberlain's record of 127 consecutive NBA games with 20 points or more
By Gabriel F. Cordero, Sun, 15 Mar 2026World-Ranked Light Heavyweight Najee Lopez Stops Mexican Terminator Manuel Gallego in Eight Classic Rounds in Main Event of ProBoxTV’s ‘The Contender Series’
Sat, 14 Mar 2026Weigh-in from Highland Boxing in Bangkok, Thailand; Dologuin in Action (WEIGH-IN PHOTOS)
Sat, 14 Mar 2026Oval rules 35th CityHeights slugfest
By Lito delos Reyes, Sat, 14 Mar 2026Sims vs. Barboza and Dickens vs. Cacace Headline Doubleheader on DAZN
By Chris Carlson, Sat, 14 Mar 2026Rubilen Amit sustains amazing run of victories at WPBA Pool in New York
By Marlon Bernardino, Sat, 14 Mar 2026Weights Set in Anaheim: Barboza Jr. and Sims Jr. Ready for Welterweight War; Collazo Defends Titles
Sat, 14 Mar 2026Rising Young Star Yoenis Tellez Takes on Top Contender Brian Mendoza in New Co-Main Event of PBC Pay-per-View Event Available on Prime Video Saturday, March 28
Sat, 14 Mar 2026Five USA Boxers Qualify for Medal Rounds on Day Six of 2026 World Boxing Futures Cup
Sat, 14 Mar 2026