WBC PRESIDENT SULAIMAN TO ORDER IMMEDIATE REVIEW OF CONTROVERSIAL PETALCORIN-KIMWERI SILVER TITLE FIGHT
By Ronnie Nathanielsz
PhilBoxing.com
Sun, 17 Apr 2016
World Boxing Council president Mauricio Sulaiman has ordered an ?immediate review? of the hugely controversial split decision victory of Australia-based Tanzanian Omari Kimweri over Filipino southpaw Randy ?Razor? Petalcorin at the Melbourne Pavilion last Friday night.
The decision aggravated by the failure of referee Malcom Bulner to call four knockdowns by Petalcorin shocked those watching the fight on live streaming in the Philippines including some of the leading TV commentators and boxing writers.
Co-managers Jim Claude Manangquil and multi-titled Australian promoter Peter Maniatis expressed their ?shock and disgust? over the decision with highlights of the fight for the vacant WBC Silver title showing the knockdowns which Bulner unbelievably failed to count, costing Petalcorin who relinquished his WBA light flyweight Interim title to fight Kimweri for the WBC green and gold Silver belt.
This reporter communicated with WBC president Sulaiman who acted promptly and ordered a review while waiting for copy of the fight which Maniatis informed us he would send to the WBC president along with a formal protest.
In an overseas conversation early Sunday with The Standard, Maniatis said he would ask for a reversal of the decision and if that is not granted, at least a rematch promoted by someone neutral and not the manager of Kimweri who, ?violated the provisions of the Muhammad Ali Act? and appointed Bulner and all three Australian judges including Bulner?s wife Samantha who also scored the fight for Kimweri.
Aside from being shocked, Maniatis and Manangquil said it was ?horrible for boxing. This is killing the sport that we love and also hurts the boxers who work hard? pointing out that Petalcorin had trained in sweltering 42 degree heat in the Philippines before leaving for Melbourne.
Maniatis said that Randy had recovered from the painful decision after they enjoyed some ice cream together went fishing behind the home of Peter on Sunday morning.
Well-known boxing writer Ryan Songalia of Ring TV and Rappler noted that Bulner knew Kimweri was ?ahead significantly on three scorecards when he finally took a point away fore rough-housing when he had previously hit Petalcorin when he slipped in round one and hit him well after the bell at the end of round three.?
Click here to view a list of other articles written by Ronnie Nathanielsz.
Recent PhilBoxing.com In-House articles:
THE PAST WEEK IN ACTION 8 SEPTEMBER 2025: Nunez Outpoints Diaz; Iglesias Stops Shishkin; Valdez, Conlan Register Wins in Return
By Eric Armit, Tue, 09 Sep 2025Dante Kirkman Stays Undefeated Triumphing with Dominant Unanimous Decision Win
Tue, 09 Sep 2025Dream fight for Steven Sumpter vs. Undefeated Bek Nurmaganbet This Wednesday at Fontainebleau Las Vegas during ‘Canelo vs. Crawford’ Week
Tue, 09 Sep 2025Yoseline Perez and Malachi Georges Advance to Quarterfinals with Wins on Day Five of World Boxing Championships
Tue, 09 Sep 2025GM candidate Ronald Dableo's squad rules Mayor Francisco "Isko Moreno" Domagoso Inter-Barangay Chess Team Tournament, pockets P150,000
By Marlon Bernardino, Tue, 09 Sep 2025Saggap, Manayon top Heritage Aquathlon
By Lito delos Reyes, Tue, 09 Sep 2025Rizal Memorial Coliseum: The Arena That Endured War and Forged Generations of Filipino Greats
By Emmanuel Rivera, RRT, Tue, 09 Sep 2025“The Homecoming” turned into Coronation for Marco Romero
Tue, 09 Sep 2025Christopher “Pitufo” Diaz Speaks After Pushing Eduardo Nunez to the Limit in Thrilling War – A Potential Fight of the Year
Tue, 09 Sep 2025Santisima Wins But Vicelles Loses; Suarez-Navarrete Rematch Hangs in the Balance?
By Teodoro Medina Reynoso, Mon, 08 Sep 2025Locked & loaded for Lewis Crocker rematch, Paddy Donovan has prepared to be crowned the new IBF Welterweight World Champion
Mon, 08 Sep 2025Robby Gonzales Advances to Round of 16 with Win Over Cuba
Mon, 08 Sep 2025James Padua rules Marikina rapid chess championship
By Marlon Bernardino, Mon, 08 Sep 2025Remembering Gabriel ‘Flash’ Elorde: A Pilgrimage of Gratitude
By Emmanuel Rivera, RRT, Sun, 07 Sep 2025Hometown Triumph: Oscar Valdez Defeats Ricky Medina by Decision
Sun, 07 Sep 2025